A figure without its inputs
In a negotiation a figure travels alone: headroom of €133.1m, a basket of €34.1m. Whoever receives it cannot tell which inputs were stated in a document, which were read out of a note, and which somebody assumed.
That is harmless until the figure decides a position. Then the question becomes what it rests on, and by that time the working is rarely at hand.
Is each input stated, or read?
Some inputs are stated: in the example, net debt of €720.0m and adjusted operating profit of €182.0m are lines of the compliance certificate, and its schedule states €54.0m of cost savings claimed. Others are read: a note gives the timing of those savings by action, not by amount.
That €9.0m of the savings are realisable 13 to 18 months after the relevant action is a reading of that note. It may well be right. It is not what the document states, and it could matter, because the sponsor's second draft lengthens the period from 12 to 18 months.
- Net debt, stated in the certificate
- €720.0m
- Adjusted operating profit, stated
- €182.0m
- Savings claimed, in the schedule
- €54.0m
- Of which realisable 13 to 18 months out, read from a note
- €9.0m
Does the reading change the result?
Not every uncertain input matters. Here the addback is capped. Under lender draft 1, on that reading, the €45.0m realisable within 12 months exceed the cap of €36.4m; under sponsor draft 2 the €54.0m exceed the cap of €45.5m.
Whether the €9.0m fall in the first 12 months or in months 13 to 18, the Leverage figure under each draft is the same. Knowing that is itself a result, and it can be checked only with the steps in view.
What if an input is missing?
A missing input is different from an uncertain one. A test with an input missing has no result, and the product shows that as Unknown. It does not carry the last period's number forward or put in a round one.
A result that reads Met on an assumed input looks the same on the page as one that reads Met on stated figures.
What the product does about it
In the product every input carries its kind: stated in a document, or a reading or assumption nobody has confirmed. Every result that uses the second kind says so. Every figure opens the steps that produced it, each with the clause or the line it rests on.
None of this decides what the figure means for the negotiation. It makes sure the person deciding knows what they are standing on.
The matter, its parties and every figure in this article are invented.